Every PPC expert has a story they wish to clear. For Danny Gavin, the founder of Optidge, it wasn’t a failed bid strategy or a wasted campaign. It was a very simple thing—and no doubt very painful.
Danny joined me on PPC Live The Podcast, to talk about a technical issue that meant the leads generated through the landing page were not reaching the client. For one to two months, the campaigns continued to deliver qualified prospects while the client believed nothing was working.
A mistake that no one can see
At the time, Danny’s agency was still small, with only a few people managing client accounts. One client, an autism provider, was seeing healthy campaign performance within Google Ads.
The clicks increased. Cost per lead looks solid. Everything inside the stadium suggested success.
However, the client was getting very frustrated because no questions were coming.
The problem wasn’t Google ads.
It was not a landing page.
It was an email notification system.
All emails submitted through the form were successfully stored in the database, but a technical failure meant that notification emails stopped reaching the client. Since both parties did not realize that the emails had failed, the matter went unsolved for weeks.
By the time this problem was discovered, many leads were cold.
See exactly how your opponents to win.
Uncover the keywords, ads, landing pages, and strategies that drive your competitors’ paid search success—and find your next opportunity to outperform them.
Analyze your competitors
Why the emotional impact was worse than the technical problem
For Danny, the financial loss was not the hardest part. What was more difficult was the feeling that his agency had let the client down. Because the client was someone he knew personally, the mistake felt deeply personal.
His team had spent weeks proudly reporting the success of the campaign while the client saw no return on their investment. That disconnect created feelings of guilt, regret and helplessness.
As Danny explained, it felt like they took the customer’s money without delivering value—even though the campaigns themselves had worked.
Honesty was the first step
When the problem became apparent, there was no attempt to hide it. Danny believes that honesty is the only effective response when mistakes happen.
Rather than making excuses, the agency immediately investigated, exported every lead stored in the database and provided the client with all its findings. Although many of those opportunities were already frozen, at least the client had access to the data that was still available.
From there, the focus shifted from suspicion to prevention.
Building systems that stop the same mistake happens twice
The experience significantly changed the agency’s practices.
Instead of relying on a single notification email, they have introduced multiple safeguards, including:
- Including the agency in all lead notifications.
- Automatically log all leads into a shared Google Sheet.
- Regularly test forms to ensure both submissions and notifications are working correctly.
- Regular reviews and lead customers are definitely welcome.
These tests are now part of the agency’s standard operating procedures rather than presuming that the technology is working properly.
Why communication is as important as execution
Looking back, Danny believes that the technical problem was not the only problem. Communication also failed, no one had asked the simple question: “Are you really getting paid?”
Today, communication is one of Optidge’s core values.
Instead of expecting PPC professionals to handle regular customer communications and campaign management, the agency introduces dedicated account managers whose primary job is to keep customers informed.
The lesson is simple – campaign metrics alone do not define success.
Success only happens when the client gets the results you report.
Sometimes clients remember how you responded
At first, the relationship with the client ends. Danny thought the mistake had permanently damaged any trust they had built.
Years later, however, the same client reached out again about working together. In his email, he described Optidge as the most professional agency he has worked with. It reminded Danny that while clients don’t forget mistakes, they often remember how agencies responded to them.
Transparency, professionalism and a genuine effort to improve can leave a stronger impression than perfection.
Common PPC mistakes Danny still sees today
Although this incident happened years ago, Danny believes that many agencies continue to make the same mistakes.
Another big one is to focus only on traffic rather than business results. Sending visitors is no longer enough.
Effective lead generation requires understanding what happens after someone clicks.
Regularly audits accounts where agencies fail:
- Feed relevant lead data back to advertising platforms.
- Review the search terms properly and save negative keywords.
- Create landing pages tailored for the purpose of the campaign.
- Measure lead quality rather than just counting conversions.
Without these foundations, campaign development is based on incomplete information.
Where AI truly helps lead generation
Danny believes that AI has great potential to generate leads—but not in the way that many marketers expect.
One of the biggest opportunities is call analysis.
Instead of listening to every conversation manually, AI can now:
- Generate call scripts.
- Schedule calls with quality.
- Determine whether the call was a genuine sales opportunity.
- Help agencies feed qualified conversion data back to Google ads.
This allows optimization based on actual business results instead of high-level metrics.
Every click wins the customer you lose.
See where competitors are investing, what keywords are driving their results, and how you can capture more of the market.
See who is stealing your traffic
Why AI still needs human supervision
Despite embracing AI, Danny cautions against treating it as an infallible system.
Like automation within advertising platforms, AI can make mistakes, misunderstand context and confidently draw incorrect conclusions.
In industries with strict privacy requirements, such as healthcare, AI may not even be suitable for handling sensitive customer information.
His advice is to trust AI enough to improve efficiency—but always verify its work.
Human expertise is always important.
Great lesson
Every PPC expert will make mistakes.
What defines a successful agency is not to avoid it completely.
Be honest when it happens, fix the problem quickly, put safeguards in place and make sure the same problem doesn’t happen again.
As Danny puts it, a mistake is only valuable if you honestly learn from it.
Search Engine Land is owned by Semrush. We are committed to providing the highest quality of marketing articles. Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is written by an employee or paid contractor of Semrush Inc.
